President Infinity 1872 Election (version 2.0)

1872Election

Version 2.0 by OS Davis included events, a few new issues, and two new minor parties: Equal Rights and Prohibition.

Version 3.0 was updated by the Historical Scenario Commission on July 27, 2017. Download here: United States – 1872 v. 3.0

*****

The 1872 election is one of the most bizarre elections in our history. President Grant’s first term was highly controversial, involving scandals and Radical Republican Reconstruction legislation. The corruption of the administration bothered both Democrats and Republicans. However, Grant was still personally popular, as he was perceived to have been mostly beyond the scandals of his administration. As such, a disorganized Democratic Party, weakened by Reconstruction, united with unhappy, reform-minded Republicans in strengthening a new party–the Liberal Republican Party.

For the Republican, Grant and his backers had such a strong hold on that party, that he was unchallenged for the nomination, despite the controversial first term.

The Liberal Republicans field many interesting candidates, but none as powerful a figure as President Grant. The leading candidates were:eccentric newspaper editor, Horace Greeley, and former ambassador, and son of president John Quincy Adams and grandson of president John Adams, Charles Francis Adams, who had kept the British from aiding the Confederacy during the Civil War. Other candidates include popular Missouri politician Benjamin Gratz Brown, well-known civil right activist Lyman Trumbull, Supreme Court Judge David Davis, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court Salmon P. Chase and ambassador Andrew Curtin.

The Bourbon Democrats is the third part for this election. They were conservative, pro-business Democrats that would not endorse the Liberal Republicans. The candidates selected were Charles O’Conor and John Quincy Adams II, the son of the ambassador mentioned above. Both candidates refused to join this third party, but they were on the ballots anyway.

This election has many what-if scenarios:

  • What if several Republicans ganged up on Ulysses S. Grant and his corrupt political machine and fielded several candidates from many states in order to hold as many delegates as possible, so that they could choose a reform candidate? These candidates include Rutherford B. Hayes, James G. Blaine, Charles Sumner, John Sherman, Benjamin F. Butler, John C. Fremont, Ambrose Burnside and many others.
  • What if the Democrats had been better organized, more confident and fielded their own candidates like a usual election? Candidates for the Democrats include Thomas A. Hendricks, Winfield Scott Hancock, Samuel J. Tilden, John Quincy Adams II, Thomas Bayard, Salmon P. Chase, George B. McClellan, Horatio Seymour, former president Andrew Johnson, former Whig president Millard Fillmore and many others.
  • What if Samuel J. Tilden ran as the Bourbon Democrat nominee?

For the best effect, it is best that you turn off the Liberal Republicans and the Bourbon Democrats, if you turn the Democrats ON. However, the game is still highly playable if you play as every party. However, keep in mind that some politicians belong to more than one party in this scenario.

Feedback is desired.

13 thoughts on “President Infinity 1872 Election (version 2.0)

  1. Will you be putting in the labor reform party? I know that they were not very strong, but that was because of their candidates declining to run. It could be an off party with David Davis, Charles O’Conor. Joel Parker would be a VP choice(and could even be a candidate if you wanted to out him as one).

  2. put him as one*
    Also, for Ulysses S. Grant, you could add Schuyler Colfax as a VP choice since he was almost re-nominated.

  3. The Labor Reform ran Wendell Philips for governor in Massachusetts in 1876…there could be a what if somewhere of him running for President somewhere in the timeline

  4. @Nick

    Thanks, I’ll strongly consider adding him in the update. He had to have been really old then. Wendell Phillips was a major figure before the Civil War.

  5. He would have been 65. Had an ancestor write a biography about him and allow him around like a roadie…so Philips holds special place in my heart

  6. What was your ancestor’s name? My ancestors were in Massachusetts also. My most prominent ancestor at that time was a Naturalist named Charles Johnson Maynard. He researched and wrote about every animal in the Eastern United States and in the Caribbean.

  7. William Carlos Martyn from New York and his mother was Sarah Towne Martyn. Both wrote books found on Amazon.com. I need to go through all the old letters Carlos wrote to his parents while he was at school. He mentions being at Phillip’s lecture about Toussaint Louvereture.

  8. That’s really cool. I wish I had NY ancestors. I don’t think I have any. I have a NJ ancestor whose parents I’m unable to find, so it is possible they just moved a state South.

  9. LDS Church has family research libraries which will give you access to ancestry.com for free. I need to go to do research about an ancestor who died in the Philippines during the Philippines-American War in 1902

  10. I just finished playing as every party (Rep- Grant, Lib-Rep Greeley, Dem – Chase, Bourbon – Dem O’Conor) and it was the best campaign I’ve done in this game. It came down to the last week to three states between Greeley and Grant and somehow Horace pulled it off

  11. Enjoy the updates; playing as Woodhull or Black is damn difficult, though, i’ll warn you.

    @VCCzar’s scenario is indeed amazing to play, particularly if you activate some of the non-existent IRL parties. Very often, it’s a hard-fought, three-party race…

  12. Additional Dems:
    Jeremiah Black
    James Bayard

    John Stevenson of Kentucky was also a candidate for VP. I figure if the Democrats had run a ticket instead of endorsing the Liberal Republicans, the ticket would have been Black/Stevenson.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *